Review: Reinventing Banking by Johan Kestens

• "We have learned that risk awareness should be as much a part of a banker's DNA as commercial astuteness."
  

There's no shortage of 20-20 hindsight masquerading as confident prediction now that business is getting used to the turmoil of the markets. But this paper from AT Kearney's Johan Kesten is that rare commodity: a clear and well-argued agenda for getting banking back on track, complete with convincing examples and actionable advice.

Kestens summarises the origins of the current financial crisis, focusing on the drying up of public debt in the late 90s, the systemic errors made in the risk ratings of new types of credit derivatives, and the breakdown of mark-to-market valuation models. He also pinpoints issues of governance, organisational culture and regulatory failure. Acknowledging that customers' appetite for innovative investment products is unsurprisingly low in the light of evaporating confidence, Kestens suggests that memories are short: "Will greed surface again over the next three years?"

Kestens marshals seven ideas that banks can use to rebuild their capabilities and reputations. His first area is risk management, where he calls for proper appreciation of risk management throughout the management ranks, more equitable compensation schemes, alternative risk assessment models, scenario planning and simulation ("war games"), new reinsurance strategies and improved risk reporting.

His second area is the redefinition of business scope, starting with an improved understanding of the organisation's actual versus stated scope. He advocates concentrating on core competencies, citing winners who've stuck to the knitting and losers who've diversified away from what they know best. He advocates shielding lines of business from capital markets by making greater use of internal financing - implying that institutions have been lazy in their use of their own resources. Kestens remarks that organisational excellence, including reporting, is a competitive advantage. He recommends focused acquisitions and disposals, and greater use of outsourcing.

The third area of attention is product reinvention. Here Kesten advises banks to counter the natural commoditisation of banking products through the use of affinity, emotion and loyalty - offering real ideas for repositioning product lines. He also discusses product and feature bundling, and customer life stage modelling.

The fourth area for concern is the rebuilding of brand and trust. Consistency, emotional connection, and full and transparent communication are the keynotes here. This section segues neatly into "Do real marketing", an appeal for banks to get better at event-based marketing, and to work harder to understand online behaviours - especially the wealth of intelligence being generated in social networks.

Kestens' last two areas for attention concern distribution and IT. On the distribution side, he urges better mastery of online channels and greater recognition of contemporary customers' savvy, while advocating better management of the purpose, design and location of physical branches. In the IT arena, Kestens makes good arguments for service oriented architecture (SOA) and, perhaps surprisingly, careful systems design - the days when it was okay to assume that computing power is free and limitless have gone. He also makes sound points on the need for careful sequencing of change in IT; programme management is a notorious tanktrap for IT transformation.

The full text of the paper - which includes a valuable appendix on the future of investment banking - is available here.

On Provocation Selling

Here's an idea: tell your customers what they should be worrying about. That's the proposal made by by Philip Lay, Todd Hewlin, and Geoffrey Moore in a recent issue of the Harvard Business Review (In a downturn, provoke your customers). Instead of trying to sell people the products you've made, or listening to their needs and matching them to the goods and/or services you supply, you take them a big, juicy issue and show them why they should be really, really concerned about it. Instead of asking them what keeps them awake at night, bring them something that will destroy any sweet dreams they're still capable of harbouring.

Lay, Hewlin and Moore advocate that you identify a critical issue, develop a provocative proposition based on that issue, and then secure a meeting. At the meeting, you lodge the provocation - and see what comes back at you. If the reaction isn't positive, you "retreat with dignity". If the reaction is good, you can move on to discussing war stories, and then offer to conduct a short, diagnostic study. 

I don't know that this approach is unique to the downturn, because I've seen it used effectively in boomtimes too. If it's done with too little preparation, the perps get known as scare consultants: they turn up every few months with a new strain of business-birdbrain-birdflu that's going to wipe everyone out unless the correct vaccines are ordered immediately. Most targets pass on these scare tactics, waiting to see if anyone else buys the line.

But if you have a good working relationship with your customers, then they won't see this approach as scare tactics. They'll accept that you're bringing the issue forward - together with a means of tackling the issue - because you care about the relationship and its continuance. 

This ought to be common sense; but I've noticed that some service suppliers have incorrectly internalised the principle of offering "no surprises" and now interpret it as meaning "no bad news". It's worth remembering that if there's something in the environment that's going to bite and maybe swallow your customer, that's a kind of surprise they don't want. As a trusted partner, it's part of your duty to zap these incoming asteroids before they hit the surface.

A further warning: don't feel you need to manufacture an issue in order to justify a provocation. Do some real research. Ask your people what the issues are in your domain, and you'll quickly discover the topics that your best folks feel aren't getting the airtime they desperately need. With so many of the old certainties stuck in intensive care, now is a good time to reflect critically on where your customers are heading - and how you can help them avoid the obstacles lurking over the horizon.